Hazaaron voices on Hazare

Hazaaron voices on Hazare

As Anna Hazare's standoff with the government over his right to protest entered the third day, literati, glitterati, twitterati and other talking heads waxed eloquent. There were kudos and barbs from acolytes and cynics alike. Fence-sitters and tongue-in-cheekers joined the fray.

Here's the pick of what's around. And if you find something that's not yet here but should be, point us to it.

In a corrosive op-ed in The New York Times, Open magazine editor Manu Joseph flayed the corruptibility of the Indian middle-class:

"Indians have a deep and complicated relationship with corruption. As in any long marriage, it is not clear whether they are happily or unhappily married. The country's economic system is fused with many strands of corruption and organized systems of tax evasion. The middle class is very much a part of this."

Ever the artful bugler, author Chetan Bhagat declared on Twitter that The Guardian had requested him to do a piece on the "Anna movement". While he admits that "it has... become cool to be righteous", here's the crux of his illuminating analysis:

"How has a sleepy, defeatist India suddenly been galvanized into action? Why do our people, used to a feudal-colonial setup for centuries, suddenly want their politicians to be accountable, rather than treat them like kings? It is difficult to answer these questions at the moment, as we are still in the middle of the movement. However, a few things are clear: India seems to have suddenly woken up to an intense craving for the good and the honest."

Samar Halarnkar, writing in The Hindustan Times, argued that he finds it hard to relate to the "extreme passions" of this movement. He asks: "Have we ever stood by Irom Sharmila Devi, the Manipuri woman who has been on a hospital bed for a decade, force fed through tubes because she is on a hunger strike to have a draconian security law removed?" Unfortunate that an activist who has been fasting interminably for the last twelve years without food or water for the repeal of the Armed Forces Special Powers Act must be introduced for the benefit of the reader while those who flock to Anna hardly know of (or care for) his real cause or his antecedents. Halarnkar's analysis doubles as a warning:

"This is a protest, not a revolution. I sense a lack of emotional proportion and a troubling hypocrisy from a middle class that refuses to get as moved to action by graver things, such as the murder of female children, child labor in homes, hotels and factories, or poverty outside our car windows."

But why Anna and not, say, Swami Agnivesh or Kiran Bedi, or even Baba Ramdev? Precisely the question that Raman Kirpal addressed in FirstPost. "After all," he writes, "Anna was hardly a nationally known figure. And despite the fact that he had worked wonders for his own village, he did not have a huge following even in his home state of Maharashtra." Hazare, he argues, was "an afterthought" for the movement's real spearheads. The writer's clinching analysis:

"Despite having many detractors and with a reputation for stubbornness, everybody was clear on one thing: he was personally incorruptible."

While high-flying commentators make hay, the king of low-cost flying Captain G R Gopinath has called out to fellow captains (of the industry, as we understand) to support the movement. Airing his disappointment to DNA about the lack of corporate participation in showing solidarity with Hazare, he said: "Corporate bigwigs should have come voluntarily. They have not been speaking openly and clearly."

Perhaps he had not yet heard of Shailesh Saraf, Morgan Stanley vice president who has flown down from Hong Kong to join Anna's protest.

Gopinath, who contested the 2009 Lok Sabha elections as an independent candidate and lost, criticized the government for misunderstanding Hazare's intentions:

"The UPA thinks the Jan Lokpal Bill is against it. However, Anna Hazare has clearly mentioned the bill is not against the ruling party, but against political parties and governments that have allowed corruption to increase."

Nearly everyone enjoyed a big fat smirk reacting to the announcement of a certain Sri B S Yeddyurappa to join Anna's crusade. Mid-Day reported that Yeddy arrived at Freedom Park in Bangalore this morning to join the campaign in support of Anna. The shamed former Chief Minister was quoted as saying:

"The government was wrong in arresting Anna Hazare and it was absolutely unjustified. I want to join the common man in their fight against corruption."

Even before the rest of the Tweetosphere had finished chuckling, @rameshsrivats tweeted:

"Yeddy to join Anna movement. After getting anticipatory bail for graft charges. He can shout slogans against himself."